How should the church handle sin amongst its members, or should it?
The Current Situation
Church discipline no longer seems to be seen as an essential part of the modern church and even holiness seems to be rarely discussed or preached upon. In fact many Christians would struggle to be able to clearly express what holiness is or its place in the church.
Churches seem to think that there role is to preach the gospel (if they even faithfully do that) and to “allow the Holy Spirit to convict those living outside the message”. They seem to have lost all focus on mutual accountability and the responsibility of each of us and of the church leaders to exhort each other to holiness.
Ablert Mohler says “The decline of church discipline is perhaps the most visible failure of the contemporary church.” As the society has moved to moral relativism, so has the church. Where society once had a moral stance that individuals were expected to follow, now it is seen that each individual has the right to full self-determinisation. Unfortunately, the church has followed in the same path. It does so at its own peril and whilst it chooses to continue to do so it will continue to experience a lack of holiness.
The church is meant to be a representation of God’s holiness on the earth and yet statistics show that the lack of morality in the church is at the same statistical rates as those not in the church. How did this happen? It happened largely because the church gave up its responsibility to expect holiness from its members; instead choosing to leave it to the Holy Spirit to convict people. Yet this is not the Biblical approach.
Consider Galatians 6:1 where it says that if someone is caught in sin, those who are spiritual should restore him gently. At large this seems to be interpreted with the focus on gently, to the extent that it becomes, we need to be gentle with one who is caught in sin, and the concept of restoration is almost lost completely. What about passages like 2 Tim 3:16 which talks about how scripture is good for rebuking and correcting.
There are also passages such as Gal 5 and 1 Cor 5 where Christians are told not to associate with those who do not practice holiness. Yet, when is the last time you saw a church actually exclude someone from fellowship because they resisted efforts of discipline? Although it does still happen, it is very rare and most churches do not follow this scriptural guideline.
So how do we discipline?
Discipline is about training in righteousness. Yes, teaching is part of this. It is vital that through disicipleship and preaching that a clear standard for holiness is preached. However, it is also vital that a culture of restoration be created, whereby people understand that they have a responsibility to look out for each other, and if sin is observed, to be loving enough to talk with the other person about what has been observed. If the person engaging in sin refuses to give up the sin that they are involved in (this can be a process sometimes!), then they should ultimately be excluded from the fellowship of believers.
What is this not?
This is not legalism. Discipline is about restoration not punishment. The only time exclusion should be implemented is where the person involved in sin resists attempts at discipline.
We must fulfil our responsibility!
Yes, ultimately it is the Holy Spirit’s job to convict people and bring them to repentance. However, the Holy Spirit through the scriptures has also given each of us who believe a responsibility to be part of that process. We not only fail each other but we fail our Lord Jesus Christ when we refuse to carry out his mission on earth the way that he has asked us to do through the scriptures.
I would encourage you to understand your responsibility in this area either as a leader or just as a believer and begin to actively live out a life not only that demonstrates holiness but that demands it (in love!) from other believers.
Appendix A – Resources and Articles
• “How to practice church discipline”, Bill Zimmer, (This has a really good section on love and church discipline).
• “Church Discipline: The Missing Mark”, R. Albert Mohaler, Jr.,
• “Church Discipline”, J. Hampton Keathley, III,
• “What does the Bible say about church discipline/excommunication?”